Energy management

Spot price or monthly market value: Which billing model pays off in direct marketing?

When directly marketing PV power, the right billing model determines your revenues. Whether billing based on the spot price or the monthly market value is more worthwhile for you depends on how your PV system is operated and your individual preferences. Find out which option suits you best.

When directly marketing PV power, the right billing model determines your revenues. Whether billing based on the spot price or the monthly market value is more worthwhile for you depends on how your PV system is operated and your individual preferences. Find out which option suits you best.

Written by:

Anne Fischer

Aerial view of an industrial building with a large rooftop photovoltaic system and truck loading docks

Many photovoltaic system operators want to sell their surplus electricity as profitably as possible. Various remuneration options are available. This article explores the possibilities of direct marketing. [1][2][8][9]

This article answers the following questions for you:

  • What is direct marketing and when is it worthwhile?

  • What direct marketing options are available?

  • What are the advantages and disadvantages of billing based on spot price vs. monthly market value?

  • What impact do the EEG and negative prices have on choosing the right model?

  • How do you find out which option suits you best?

What is direct marketing?

Definition of direct marketing

When a photovoltaic system produces more electricity than is consumed on-site, there are various ways to receive remuneration for the surplus electricity. In addition to the classic feed-in tariff, operators can also sell the electricity via what is known as direct marketing. [1][2][8][9]

With the classic feed-in tariff, the surplus electricity is fed into the public grid in exchange for a statutory, fixed amount. In direct marketing, by contrast, the electricity is sold on the power exchange by a specialized company. [1][2][8][9]

Because exchange prices are sometimes higher than the feed-in tariff, this model opens up the opportunity for higher revenues. [9]

In direct marketing, plant operators can choose between different billing variants. Billing at the spot price and at the monthly market value are particularly relevant. [1][2][8][9]

While the spot price takes into account the actual exchange prices at the time of individual feed-in, the monthly market value uses the average exchange value of solar electricity generated in Germany as the billing basis. [1][2][8][9]

Which variant is more advantageous depends, among other things, on the characteristics and operating mode of the PV system, as well as on the individual preferences of the plant operators. [1][2][4][6][11][12]

The obligation for direct marketing

Many operators of larger photovoltaic systems are now required to engage in direct marketing. This applies in particular to systems with an installed capacity of more than 100 kW. [6][7]

However, there are exceptions: Operators of PV systems with an output of up to 200 kW can now alternatively feed their surplus electricity to the grid operator without remuneration. This can be worthwhile especially with very high self-consumption, when the proceeds from marketing the remaining surplus electricity do not cover the associated costs. [6][7]

Market premiums through subsidized direct marketing

If the PV system is eligible for subsidies under the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG), subsidized direct marketing is also an option. In this case, the proceeds from the electricity sale are supplemented by the statutory market premium. [1][2][3][5][8][9]

In subsidized direct marketing, revenue for plant operators generally consists of two components:

  1. Marketing revenue: The direct marketer sells the fed-in electricity on the power exchange. It then pays out the proceeds to the plant operator according to the agreed billing model—either at the spot price or at market value. [1][2][8][9]

  2. Market premium: The grid operator also pays a market premium. It generally compensates for the difference between the strike price (applied value) and the solar market value. The strike price is the legally established support level for the PV system. The solar market value, on the other hand, reflects the average exchange value of solar electricity in the respective month. [1][2][3][5][8][9]

Direct marketing at spot price or monthly market value: What is the difference?

 Photovoltaikanlage auf einem Gewerbegebäude im Morgenlicht

For the payout of marketing revenues, plant operators can primarily choose between the following two billing models:

  • Billing at spot price: Remuneration is based on the actual exchange prices at the times the PV system fed electricity into the grid. The revenue thus depends on how much electricity the system generated and fed in, and at what price. [1][2][8][9]

  • Billing at monthly market value: The amount of electricity fed in is remunerated at the published solar market value for the respective month. The exact times the individual PV system actually generated and fed in electricity are irrelevant. The solar market value is calculated centrally by the four German transmission system operators and published in the market value overview on Netztransparenz. [1][2][8][9][10]

Put simply: When billing at the spot price, the individual generation profile of the PV system is decisive. Billing at the monthly market value, on the other hand, is based on the average value of solar electricity generated in Germany in the respective month. [1][2][8][9][10]

When is billing at spot price worthwhile?

High exchange prices pay off

If your PV system feeds electricity into the grid at times with high exchange prices, billing at the spot price is particularly attractive for you. It usually enables higher revenues than billing at the monthly market value.

Conversely, revenues are lower if feed-in takes place predominantly during midday hours with low exchange prices. [1][2][8][9]

Billing at the spot price therefore opens up opportunities for additional revenues in direct marketing, but does not guarantee them.

How the orientation of your system influences spot price revenues

In the spot price model, the specific times at which the respective PV system actually feeds in electricity are crucial. The generation profile of an east-west system, distributed throughout the day, can therefore translate directly into higher revenues. [1][2][8][9]

South-facing PV systems generate a large amount of electricity, particularly around midday—precisely when many other systems are also running at full capacity and exchange prices are correspondingly low due to high supply. The result: lots of electricity, but comparatively low revenue. [11][12]

East-west systems, on the other hand, distribute their electricity generation more evenly throughout the day: The east-facing section feeds in during the morning, while the west-facing section feeds in during the afternoon and early evening.

This means: Although total yield may be slightly lower for east-west systems than for south-facing systems, a larger share of electricity is generated at times of higher exchange prices. [11][12]

Orientation plays no role in the monthly market value

When billing at the monthly market value, this potential advantage is not taken into account: Regardless of orientation, the fed-in electricity is remunerated at the monthly solar market value.

This average value is heavily influenced by electricity generation during the typical midday peak, when exchange prices are frequently comparatively low due to the high solar electricity supply. Naturally, orientation can still influence the direct marketer's service fee. [1][2][8][9][10]

Ost-West ausgerichtete Photovoltaikanlage auf einem Gewerbegebäude

Surplus feed-in: Why irregularities become an advantage with the spot price

Billing at the spot price can also offer advantages with surplus feed-in. In systems with surplus feed-in, the feed-in profile is usually irregular and difficult to predict due to self-consumption. This is precisely what can turn into an advantage in the spot price model: 

Because only the electricity volumes actually fed into the grid are remunerated at the respective exchange prices, the marketing result is directly aligned with the system's individual feed-in behavior rather than a flat average value. As a result, the risk markup that the direct marketer adds to the service fee due to the unknown feed-in profile generally decreases.[1][2][8][9]

As a general rule: The more irregularly a system feeds in power, the more it can benefit from the spot price model. With the monthly market value, on the other hand, the exact same average value always applies regardless of actual feed-in behavior.

When is billing at monthly market value worthwhile?

Billing at the monthly market value is particularly suitable for operators who place great value on predictable revenues.

When billing at the monthly market value, remuneration is based on a monthly average value and therefore does not depend on the specific feed-in times of your PV system. Short-term fluctuations in exchange prices are thus smoothed out, making revenues generally easier to plan than with spot price billing. [1][2][8][9][10]

However, this higher predictability can come with additional costs: The direct marketer may charge a risk surcharge in the service fee for the price risk it assumes under this billing model. [Source]

When billing at the spot price, such a risk buffer can be eliminated. In this case, you receive the actual market value of your feed-in, while the direct marketer assumes no additional price or volume risk. [1][2][8][9]

Effects of negative electricity prices on marketing revenues

Negative exchange electricity prices are occurring with increasing frequency and can directly impact the marketing revenues of PV operators. 

To evaluate which billing model is suitable for you, examining the following distinctions can be helpful: 

  1. New vs. existing systems and the influence of the EEG

  2. Billing at spot price vs. monthly market value

New systems vs. existing systems: The influence on the market premium

During periods of negative electricity prices, the market premium is forfeited for new systems under EEG regulations.

This means: Every kilowatt-hour fed in during these periods can worsen marketing revenues. 

Put simply, plant operators then pay for feeding electricity into the grid. It can therefore make economic sense for new systems to curtail or completely halt feed-in during negative prices.

Older systems are exempt from these regulations: Even if they continue to feed in during negative prices, they receive the market premium. [4]

Information on whether your PV system is considered an existing or new system can be found in the following table. [13]


Commissioning

Regulation

Up to EEG 2017 (existing systems)

No restriction. The market premium remains even during negative prices.

2021 to 2022

The market premium is eliminated after 4 consecutive hours of negative prices.

January 1, 2023 to February 24, 2025

The market premium is eliminated in tiers after 3 to 1 consecutive hours.

From February 25, 2025 (Solar Peak Act)

The market premium is eliminated starting from the first negative quarter hour.


Operators of new systems therefore benefit from taking a closer look at their billing model and feed-in strategy, whereas this is less critical for operators of existing systems. 

Billing at spot price: Curtailment during negative prices pays off

During periods of negative electricity prices, billing at the spot price can be advantageous. This applies in particular to new systems.

When billing at the spot price, only the exchange prices during the time intervals in which the system actually fed in electricity are taken into account. If a new system curtails during negative prices, these time intervals are simply omitted from its settlement. This prevents negative marketing revenues. 

The economic benefit of curtailment is thus reflected directly in the result. [1][2][8][9]

Billing at monthly solar market value: Curtailment during negative prices is disregarded

Curtailment during negative price hours is not taken into account when calculating the monthly solar market value. 

This means that regardless of whether an individual PV system actually fed in power during negative hours or not, the negative price hours automatically factor into the monthly solar market value. The calculation is based on the determined projection of solar power generation by the four transmission system operators. [1][2][8][9][10]

This has an important consequence: Even new systems that have curtailed power impeccably during negative prices can be adversely affected in their billing by a decreased monthly market value.

What do negative hours mean for you as a plant operator?

Whether and how heavily negative price hours affect your marketing revenue depends significantly on the chosen billing model: 

  • New system + spot price: Consistent curtailment during negative prices protects you directly against negative marketing revenues.

  • New system + monthly market value: Your revenue can be impacted even if you did not feed in any power at all during negative price hours.

  • Existing system: You are largely unaffected by these considerations.

Spot price or monthly market value in direct marketing: Which should you choose?

Whether billing at the spot price or the monthly market value is the better choice for you depends primarily on the characteristics and operating mode of your photovoltaic system, as well as on your personal priorities. [1][2][4][6][11][12]

Billing at the spot price can be particularly worthwhile if your PV system feeds in at times of comparatively high exchange prices or if you can flexibly adjust feed-in to current price signals. 

Billing at the monthly market value, on the other hand, balances out short-term price fluctuations and can therefore provide more predictable revenues. [1][2][8][9][10]

Before making your decision, you should therefore analyze the historical or projected feed-in profile of your PV system and weigh the opportunity for higher revenues against your desire for predictable earnings.

trawa analyzes your feed-in profile, evaluates your priorities, and gives you a sound assessment of which variant is best suited to you.

Feel free to schedule an appointment with us.

Sources

[1] Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection. (n.d.). Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG 2023): § 3 Definitions. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/eeg_2014/__3.html

[2] Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection. (n.d.). Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG 2023): § 19 Entitlement to payment. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/eeg_2014/__19.html

[3] Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection. (n.d.). Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG 2023): § 20 Market premium. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/eeg_2014/__20.html

[4] Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection. (n.d.). Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG 2023): § 51 Reduction of the entitlement to payment in case of negative prices. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/eeg_2014/__51.html

[5] Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection. (n.d.). Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG 2023): Annex 1 (to § 23a): Amount of the market premium. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/eeg_2014/anlage_1.html

[6] Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy. (n.d.). Flexibilization of the direct marketing obligation. https://www.bundeswirtschaftsministerium.de/Redaktion/DE/Dossier/Energieversorgung/solarpaket-1_1flexibilisierung-der-direktvermarktungspflicht.html

[7] Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy. (n.d.). Solar Package I. https://www.bundeswirtschaftsministerium.de/Redaktion/DE/Artikel/Energie/solarpaket-1.html

[8] Federal Network Agency. (n.d.). Solar systems and other renewable energy installations. https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/DE/Fachthemen/ElektrizitaetundGas/ErneuerbareEnergien/Solaranlagen/start.html

[9] Gieße, A. (2026, February 3). Direct marketing of PV electricity: Selling solar energy on the exchange. ADAC. https://www.adac.de/rund-ums-haus/energie/spartipps/direktvermarktung-pv-strom/#was-ist-die-direktvermarktung

[10] Netztransparenz. (n.d.). Market value overview. https://www.netztransparenz.de/de-de/Erneuerbare-Energien-und-Umlagen/EEG/Transparenzanforderungen/Marktprämie/Marktwertübersicht

[11] Peper, D. & Hanisch, C. (2022, August 4). Short study by Fraunhofer ISE: Dismantling regulatory hurdles leads to more rooftop PV systems up to 30 kW. Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems. https://www.ise.fraunhofer.de/de/presse-und-medien/presseinformationen/2022/kurzstudie-des-fraunhofer-ise-abbau-regulatorischer-huerden-fuehrt-zu-mehr-pv-dachanlagen-bis-30-kw.html

[12] VDE VERLAG. (2025, April 22). East-West vs. South: Optimal orientation for solar farms in a volatile power market. energie.de. https://www.energie.de/sonne-wind-waerme/news-detailansicht/nsctrl/detail/News/ost-west-vs-sued-die-optimale-ausrichtung-fuer-solarparks-im-volatilen-strommarkt

Many businesses pay too much for energy. That’s exactly where we come in. Let’s have a chat.

Free of charge & no obligation

First consultation: approx. 25 mins

No preparation required

Many businesses pay too much for energy. That’s exactly where we come in. Let’s have a chat.

Free of charge & no obligation

First consultation: approx. 25 mins

No preparation required

Many businesses pay too much for energy. That’s exactly where we come in. Let’s have a chat.

Free of charge & no obligation

First consultation: approx. 25 mins

No preparation required

Many businesses pay too much for energy. That’s exactly where we come in. Let’s have a chat.

Free of charge & no obligation

First consultation: approx. 25 mins

No preparation required

Have questions? We have the answers.

Do I have to commit to a long-term contract if I use wind power?

What information can I view on the Trawa Energy Portal?

How does trawa’s electricity procurement work?

What is the minimum electricity requirement to be able to use trawa’s electricity supply?

How much can I save on my electricity bills with trawa?

What are PPAs and how do they work in the trawa system?

How does trawa protect me from price fluctuations?

Do I have to sort out the purchasing myself?

What are the benefits of trawa’s green electricity procurement?

What happens if my consumption pattern changes?

Can trawa handle supply for several company sites?

trawa Newsletter

Your overview of the energy market

Current insights into the energy market and expert knowledge on professional power supply for small and medium-sized businesses.

trawa Newsletter

Your overview of the energy market

Current insights into the energy market and expert knowledge on professional power supply for small and medium-sized businesses.

trawa Newsletter

Your overview of the energy market

Current insights into the energy market and expert knowledge on professional power supply for small and medium-sized businesses.

×
Kostenloses Live-Webinar

MiSpeL: Neue Regeln für Batteriespeicher erweitern Ihr Erlöspotenzial

Seit 1. Oktober 2026 können Batteriespeicher Solar- und Netzstrom gemeinsam nutzen, ohne die EEG-Förderung zu verlieren. Im Live-Webinar zeigt Kai Gehrke anhand konkreter Berechnungen, wo das Potenzial liegt und was Sie 2026 noch entscheiden sollten.

Di, 24. November 2026 10:00 Uhr Live-Webinar · 30 Min. + Q&A
Kostenlos zum Webinar anmelden

Mit Kai Gehrke, Experte für Speicher und Flexibilisierung bei trawa

×
trawa Portfolio · In 3 Minuten erklärt

Lernen Sie das
trawa Portfolio kennen

Kurz Daten eintragen und direkt sehen, wie trawa Ihren Energiebezug mit KI-gesteuerter Beschaffung optimiert – Bis zu 40 % Kosten senken.